I’ve been avoiding using Emacs, my normal, every-day editor, for editing JavaScript, because the default modes are so astoundingly frustrating.1

Asking in #emacs on Freenode, I got the advice to use web-mode instead. Already having that installed, I switched over, and immediately ran into a similar frustration: indentation was all wonky.

First problem I tackled, tab indentation. Running into the code, I found this:

(defcustom web-mode-code-indent-offset
  (if (and (boundp 'standard-indent) standard-indent) standard-indent 2)
  "Code (javascript, php, etc.) indentation level."
  :type 'integer
  :group 'web-mode)

So, I just need to set this variable, right? Wrong. It was already set to 4, which is what I at least wanted to start with. (Work projects use 2 spaces as standard.)

I looked in the wee test file I was using and found that the value had been changed to 8 locally. Global value was still 4. Okay, what’s changing it locally?

Searching through web-mode.el, I found it was being set in web-mode-use-tabs, which was a little strange.

(defun web-mode-use-tabs ()
  "Tweaks vars to be compatible with TAB indentation."
  (let (offset)
    (setq web-mode-block-padding 0)
    (setq web-mode-script-padding 0)
    (setq web-mode-style-padding 0)
    (setq offset
           ((and (boundp 'tab-width) tab-width) tab-width)
           ((and (boundp 'standard-indent) standard-indent) standard-indent)
           (t 4)))
    ;;    (message "offset(%S)" offset)
    (setq web-mode-attr-indent-offset offset)
    (setq web-mode-code-indent-offset offset)
    (setq web-mode-css-indent-offset offset)
    (setq web-mode-markup-indent-offset offset)
    (setq web-mode-sql-indent-offset offset)
    (add-to-list 'web-mode-indentation-params '("lineup-args" . nil))
    (add-to-list 'web-mode-indentation-params '("lineup-calls" . nil))
    (add-to-list 'web-mode-indentation-params '("lineup-concats" . nil))
    (add-to-list 'web-mode-indentation-params '("lineup-ternary" . nil))

Why would it be using tabs? Sure enough, searching for that function, I found a little further where the mode is actually defined (define-derived-mode web-mode) it calls web-mode-use-tabs when the variable indent-tabs-mode is not nil.

(define-derived-mode web-mode web-mode-prog-mode "Web"
  "Major mode for editing web templates."

  ;; ...

  (when (and (boundp 'indent-tabs-mode) indent-tabs-mode)

  ;; ...

Voila. I then set indent-tabs-mode to nil in my global settings, reloaded emacs, and now web-mode uses the setting of 4 for indents.


I’m hoping this will actually help, now.

  1. What I’ve been using instead is JetBrain’s WebStorm, which is actually a really wonderful alternative, but I don’t want to fire it up if I just have to tweak a couple .js or .json files.